Blood, blight, darkness, slaughter
Dec. 28th, 2021 11:10 amDespite having been somewhat disappointed in The Witches of New York I decided that I was indeed going to add All The Witch Books Whose Titles I Keep Getting Mixed Up to my library holds list, and thus my Christmas plane reading this weekend ended up being Alexis Henderson’s horror novel The Year of the Witching.
It is perhaps a mark of how tired I am with everything that when I read the basic premise–feminist horror-fantasy about a misogynistic, Puritan-esque society getting its comeuppance–I was not quite as excited as I have historically been about that sort of thing and was instead worried that it would be, perhaps, a bit done, or perhaps that it would have the same sort of glib girl-power sensibility as Witches of New York that thought it was fresher and more radical than it was. But I had heard only good things about The Year of the Witching whereas I had in fact heard in advance that Witches of New York was a bit, hm, white.
I need not have worried, because even with living here in Massachusetts, a 45-minute drive from the tasteless Gothic Disneyland of Salem, where I learn stuff about Puritans all the livelong day whether I care about it or not (I do, though; they were interesting), The Year of the Witching was still weird and new and different. For starters, the religion of Bethel, while in many respects matching quite closely what I’ve learned about agrarian Puritan colonies in the times of the witch trials, a lot of it is… bloodier. Animal sacrifice features prominently, and marriages are marked by having a sigil cut into the bride’s forehead, in a ceremony known as “cutting.” Polygamy is common, with the “prophets”--the high-ranking men of the church–claiming more wives the higher up the hierarchy they are. Bethel is a very, very closed community, living in fear of the Darkwoods, where the Mother and her malevolent witch followers are in power, and of the “heathen” cities of the rest of the world. Obviously as readers we are inclined to be at least a bit Team Darkwoods even though we know this is a horror novel and the malevolent witches are probably going to do malevolent stuff.
Our protagonist, Immanuelle, is the orphan daughter of two teenagers who were executed for a series of crimes that centered on their trying to be together instead of quietly letting Immanuelle’s mum get sold off at the tender age of 16 to the current Prophet, who is both mean and several years her senior. Admittedly this series of crimes did involve Immanuelle’s mom trying to murder the Prophet with his own sacred dagger but all things considered, this was a sensible and righteous course of action and I support it fully. Immanuelle has thus grown up under the shadow of her mother’s excommunication and is not very popular. However, despite her attempts to keep her head down and not make a fuss, Immanuelle finds herself all mixed up in a series of horrifying plagues that start afflicting the town, and is stuck in the role of “only person who can stop them” since they are definitely mixed up with her mother’s history, if she can only figure out how. As such, with periodic help from her obligatory male love interest (the prophet’s son and heir, whomst has questions about what a dick his father is), Immanuelle has to uncover her family history and set Bethel on a path to, to put it bluntly, not being the sort of place that people wind up with good reasons to set horrible plagues upon.
Overall I found this book to be pleasantly creepy and quite engaging. It certainly had some familiar beats but mostly was able to keep me wondering what fucked-up thing was going to happen next.
It is perhaps a mark of how tired I am with everything that when I read the basic premise–feminist horror-fantasy about a misogynistic, Puritan-esque society getting its comeuppance–I was not quite as excited as I have historically been about that sort of thing and was instead worried that it would be, perhaps, a bit done, or perhaps that it would have the same sort of glib girl-power sensibility as Witches of New York that thought it was fresher and more radical than it was. But I had heard only good things about The Year of the Witching whereas I had in fact heard in advance that Witches of New York was a bit, hm, white.
I need not have worried, because even with living here in Massachusetts, a 45-minute drive from the tasteless Gothic Disneyland of Salem, where I learn stuff about Puritans all the livelong day whether I care about it or not (I do, though; they were interesting), The Year of the Witching was still weird and new and different. For starters, the religion of Bethel, while in many respects matching quite closely what I’ve learned about agrarian Puritan colonies in the times of the witch trials, a lot of it is… bloodier. Animal sacrifice features prominently, and marriages are marked by having a sigil cut into the bride’s forehead, in a ceremony known as “cutting.” Polygamy is common, with the “prophets”--the high-ranking men of the church–claiming more wives the higher up the hierarchy they are. Bethel is a very, very closed community, living in fear of the Darkwoods, where the Mother and her malevolent witch followers are in power, and of the “heathen” cities of the rest of the world. Obviously as readers we are inclined to be at least a bit Team Darkwoods even though we know this is a horror novel and the malevolent witches are probably going to do malevolent stuff.
Our protagonist, Immanuelle, is the orphan daughter of two teenagers who were executed for a series of crimes that centered on their trying to be together instead of quietly letting Immanuelle’s mum get sold off at the tender age of 16 to the current Prophet, who is both mean and several years her senior. Admittedly this series of crimes did involve Immanuelle’s mom trying to murder the Prophet with his own sacred dagger but all things considered, this was a sensible and righteous course of action and I support it fully. Immanuelle has thus grown up under the shadow of her mother’s excommunication and is not very popular. However, despite her attempts to keep her head down and not make a fuss, Immanuelle finds herself all mixed up in a series of horrifying plagues that start afflicting the town, and is stuck in the role of “only person who can stop them” since they are definitely mixed up with her mother’s history, if she can only figure out how. As such, with periodic help from her obligatory male love interest (the prophet’s son and heir, whomst has questions about what a dick his father is), Immanuelle has to uncover her family history and set Bethel on a path to, to put it bluntly, not being the sort of place that people wind up with good reasons to set horrible plagues upon.
Overall I found this book to be pleasantly creepy and quite engaging. It certainly had some familiar beats but mostly was able to keep me wondering what fucked-up thing was going to happen next.