Dreams, drugs, and demons
Aug. 15th, 2023 01:05 pmDespite the YA X-of-Y-and-Z structure of the title, this is not a YA book! In tone and subject it is definitely a book for adults, albeit a rather short one. It’s got too much drugs and sex and art galleries to be a YA book. The main character, Liz, is actually asexual, but this seems to mostly mean that she spends most of her time moping over her best friend, whereas everybody else spends most of their time moping over their romantic partners, and Liz’ boyfriend splits his time between moping over Liz and moping over somebody else’s girlfriend.
I’ll admit I didn’t like this book quite as much as I wanted to. The elaborate language just felt overwritten instead of evocative of the various wonders and horrors plaguing our dramatis personae. The blurb copy said it was supposed to be Lovecraftian but it didn’t feel Lovecraftian, it just felt… starving-artist-chic, basically. Every character has that sort of hapless quietist vibe that is why I don’t read a lot of modern literary fiction, where everybody has a PhD and everybody has read every book ever written and nobody spends any time reading or writing or doing any kind of work during the course of the story. The characters spend enough time being put physically through the wringer–continually ending up wet, underdressed, injured, sleepless, and/or drunk in the bitter midwinter in Vancouver–that they have no energy left to protag and it starts to push against my suspension of disbelief that Blake is the only one in a coma. It’s hard for me to pin down precisely what didn’t work for me–I’ve enjoyed plenty of books where the characters are pretty quiet and all the “action” is like, talking and feeling, and I’ve enjoyed plenty of books where the story takes place in dreams or otherwise in people’s minds or some other inscrutable other dimension. I don’t know if it’s because enough of the story is about GUNS and DRUGS and ATTEMPTED MURDER and MONSTERS FROM REALMS BEYOND that the poor little meow meow wet sock persona of basically everybody just didn’t do enough to carry it. Idunno, I liked a lot of the kinds of stuff in it but somehow this book just never quite got around to gelling, for me. (Maybe the fact that I don’t like books about quiet do-nothing academics overrode a lot of it. All the PhD’s I know–and I know a lot, because I live in the most overeducated metro area in the U.S.–both had to do a shit-ton of work in grad school/their PhD programs *and* manage to do, like, socialist organizing and shit.) I feel bad criticizing this book in such a vague way because frankly the things I don’t like about it also seem like failure modes I would fall into in my own writing if I ever got around to finishing something, which I have not, and Downum at least finished a book and got it published. But there were definitely a few moments where I had the feeling of “this reads like something I would write” and not in my halfway decent nonfiction writing way, either.
Overall it was basically a fine beach read, but it felt like it ought to have been the type thing I’d be absolutely captivated by, so that’s awkward.